Employee Training and Retention: The Debate between Expense and Investment – Part II

Once an effective training and development program is established and utilized by the organization it can begin seeing increases and benefits in the following areas: productivity, motivation, quality, job satisfaction, commitment (employee retention), and reduced absenteeism.

In order to provide the training and development that reaps these many benefits, it costs money, time and other resources. Paid human resources are used to plan, organize and teach training sessions, mentors take time from their own duties to mentor newer employees, training materials must be printed and/or compiled in electronic format, and fees must be paid for seminars, classes or workshops. Organizations recognize there is a cost for training and development.

In today’s competitive business world, most organizations are looking at ways to reduce expenses in order to increase profits. Unfortunately, when training is only looked at as an expense, it can be the first category to go to the chopping block. It is suggested that businesses need to accurately analyze what these training programs are worth. While most organizations compile data and trends on advertising campaigns, sales department activities, and other activities that they can directly tie to increased revenue, it can be difficult to determine a Return on Investment (ROI) on employee training and development.

Training Makes Employees Feel Valued

Research has shown, however, that when employers invest time, money and resources in their employees with training and development the employees develop a commitment to the organization. The employee feels the organization/employer values them as a worker, values their skills and values their contribution. Research has also determined that with training and development the employee believes the employer cares about the employability of the employee. (Agrawal)

In contrast, some employees have been known to say they “saw it coming” before they were fired or let go. This can be the perception when an employee is struggling and/or not performing well and the employer distances themselves from the employee; does not offer help (training/development), keeps adding additional workload, tells the employee not to worry they will eventually “get it”, etc. In other words, with ongoing training and development the employee does not feel the employer is leaving them to “sink or swim” on their own or that the employer is not “creating” a reason to fire them.

Which Came First …?

Another comment that represents the crux of this argument: “Positions that have a high turnover rate (such as tech support) are often viewed by management as not worthy of proper training.” (Green) It is “the chicken and the egg” type question. Are these positions not worthy of training due to the high turnover or is a high turnover due to the lack of training? Another point of training is to evaluate if you have the right person for the right job. Sometimes you may have a talented and capable individual but they are just in the wrong position. Continued training and development, including evaluations, can determine strengths and weaknesses and what persons fit best with various positions.

Training and employee development is not just for the employee but is as beneficial to the employer as well. For those employers that view training as an expense, a trade-off for production or just plain wasted time, they may not have an effective training program in place. Also if an employer’s turnover is high, they may need to evaluate how they train new employees, evaluate existing employees and what programs are in place to develop employees to be productive members of their organization. Employers that are successful in reducing employee turnover embrace training and employee development as a necessary tool to further their organizational goals.

We featured this excerpt from a research paper that Kim Jimenez had written on employee training and how it relates to employee engagement/retention.  Employee turnover is a real cash expense that effects your business in many ways.  MDS can help in employee orientation and training in order to help create and retain the best staff possible.

 

Roy Barker is Director of Special Projects at Moore Diversified Services, a Fort-Worth, Texas-based organization specializing in operations analysis, marketing development, and investment advisory services. Roy is an authority in the field of employee turnover analysis and retention strategies.

References

Agrawal, Archana. “Employee Development and Its Affect on Their Performance.” International Journal of Marketing, Financial Services & Management Research (2013): 99-108. Web.
Green, Allison. www.askamanger.org. 19 05 2012. Article. 05 09 2014.

Employee Training and Retention: The Debate between Expense and Investment – Part I

Most employers have some form of training implemented for their new employees and some even have programs designed for ongoing employee development. If asked, many employers, if not all, will say that training and employee development is important. But when truly evaluated, many employers do not provide adequate training or employee development to realize the advantages of proper training.

The disconnect lies in the fact that training and employee development comes at a price -financial resources, human resources and time. Employers view training as a cost or expense rather than an investment. They are hesitant, and some even resistant, to spend too many resources on an employee that may take that training elsewhere.

But, in fact, research has shown that proper training and employee development will increase employee productivity, job satisfaction and instill a higher commitment to the job among other things. This commitment to the job by the employee actually reduces employee turnover.

Investment – Not Expense

Therefore, employers need to view training and employee development as an investment in their employees which benefits both employee and employer rather than just an expense to reduce. Employers could also view this investment in training and employee development as an avenue to reduce employee turnover, in addition to, higher employee performance which benefits the organization as a whole.

Training and employee development takes many forms. There is no one training program that will fit every employee or organization. Each organization will need to determine its needs, the needs of its employees and how to address those needs in the most efficient and effective way. Some of the various components of employee training and development can include: new hire orientation, job specific training, mentoring/coaching, in-service training, continuing education, and seminars/conferences.

Orientation Alone is Not Enough

No one component itself will constitute a complete training and development program, but a combination of these components will address the various needs of both the employee and organization. For example, most organizations will have some sort of new hire orientation. And while this is a key component to any training and development program, it has its limitations as a stand-alone program.

A study published in 2008 states that while employee orientation is a necessary first step and that orientations “successfully conveyed the organization’s message on quality management initiatives and employees learned a great deal about quality management practices within the organization. The issue, however, is that transfer of learning did not take place at the desired levels after the employees returned back to their work stations.” (Akdere and Schmidt) The key to an effective program will be ongoing, continuous development using a combination of training and development components.

 

We featured this excerpt from a research paper that Kim Jimenez had written on employee training and how it relates to employee engagement/retention. The second part of this report will be in our next post.  Employee turnover is a real cash expense that effects your business in many ways.  MDS can help in employee orientation and training in order to help create and retain the best staff possible.

 

Roy Barker is Director of Special Projects at Moore Diversified Services, a Fort-Worth, Texas-based organization specializing in operations analysis, marketing development, and investment advisory services. Roy is an authority in the field of employee turnover analysis and retention strategies.

 

Reference:
Akdere, Mesut and Steven W. Schmidt. “Employee Perceptions of Quality Management: Effects of Employee Orientation Training.” 2008. The Education Resources Information Center (ERIC). Web. September 2014.

Well-deserved Pat on the Back!

I did a piece last week suggesting that employers should be quick to thank their employees to help build goodwill and employee engagement. Most of the time, all the employees are looking for is acknowledgment of their efforts. I think this also translates well to our clients, prospects, peers, competition, and our industry as a whole.

This week I was rolling out some “Thank You” offers to both our new and loyal readers and it reminded me of what a great industry in which I have the pleasure of serving! Over the last 15 years I have been involved and most of the last 40 that MDS has been in business, there have been a great many changes both good and not as good. The one thing that has remained constant is the quality of people that the industry has attracted and recruited.

Special Industry

This industry as a whole is very quick to take the heat for accidents or individual bad actors because it involves the lives of others and of course this is nothing to take lightly. On the converse, it seems that the industry as a whole is very slow to receive the praise for all the resident days that are logged not only without incident, but with successful outcomes for the seniors served.

I have had this experience from both sides of the table. Of course I work with both Senior Living operators and Senior Consumers on a daily basis, but I have also had family members in every form of Senior Living from Independent Living to Skilled Nursing. I know firsthand that overall, seniors’ lives are enriched because of the services provided. If that’s hard to wrap your head around, then just think of the lives that would be impacted if every Senior Living community closed their doors tonight.

Special People

I really enjoy the camaraderie of my friends and associates in the industry. There are several groups of professionals that serve the Senior Living industry that I meet with regularly. While we are capitalist and do need to make a living, we always consider the other group members when it comes to cross-marketing. We are very attune to opportunities where our group members can benefit.   I think because they all have a giving spirit and that seems to be a common thread throughout those who work in the Senior Living field. That is not just reserved for those who work on the front lines in the communities at the operations level, but to the vendors that serve the operators as well.

The support that people and companies in this industry give to each other is also incredible. Operators are always eager to lend a helping hand to other operators. We all share and collaborate on ways to better serve the senior population. Even vendors who compete in the same product line talk freely and share ideas with other vendors who compete directly with them.

Character Shines Through

Probably one of the most awesome features is that we don’t feel the need to “trash” our competitors in an open forum to make them look bad and us better. I write a lot and while I do get some constructive feedback from time to time, I have never had any harsh criticism. The same goes for me, if I see something I don’t agree with, running someone down in an open forum is not the right thing to do. I have been appalled as of late while reading the Pulse postings on LinkedIn at the amount of negative responses.   I don’t mean just one or two, I am talking about an entire thread of negative comments to some person’s feelings or position. I guess I follow the old adage that if you don’t have something nice to say, you don’t say anything.

Again, I am not talking about a difference of opinion that can be discussed like professional adults, but just rude and non-productive comments that add no value to the conversation and they sure don’t make the commenter look good. In fact, if the person providing the negative comment only knew how shallow and uneducated it makes them appear they would think twice about being negative or so literal to the point you put someone else down.

So, all that to say….Thanks to those who make up the Senior Living industry. From the financiers who take a chance with their money, to the operators and their awesome staff who make it happen day in and day out, and to vendors that serve them all, a BIG THANK YOU, for a job well done and for making this a great industry of which to be a part! If you’re not fortunate enough to work in the Senior Living industry, but work with equally as great people as we do, consider yourself blessed.

 

Roy Barker is Director of Special Projects at Moore Diversified Services, a Fort Worth, Texas-based organization specializing in operations analysis, marketing development, and investment advisory services. Roy is an authority in the field of employee turnover analysis and retention strategies.

 

In Whose Hands Have You Placed Your Reputation and Business?

By Roy Barker

Many people answer this question with our executives, the higher-ups, and those employees who engage the consumer. All of these choices are correct, but in the consumer’s mind the employee helping him or her is the only voice and/or face of your company.

Are your phones being answered in a timely manner? Is the voice on the other end friendly and helpful? Are visitors greeted with a friendly smile? Is your intended message being delivered by employees through their actions?

Front line employees are the ones customers base their purchasing decisions on. Quality of service is key to producing happy residents, resident/employee referrals, and added value to your company. How many times have you gone out of your way to bypass a business because the one a mile down the road has better customer service, or has gone the extra mile to resolve an issue? This happens to Senior Living communities every day because of the way a prospect was handled or not handled on the phone. Most communities are unaware of a missed opportunity.

Questions To Ask

Questions you should now be asking yourself are: am I hiring the best individuals for the task? MDS believes the first step in quality customer service is hiring the right individual. The right individual may not always be the most qualified. In most instances, it is better to base hiring on attitude, personality, and corporate culture fit, and then train skills. This may take more time in the hiring and training process but will payoff in the long run through better quality service and longevity of the employee’s tenure with the company.

Next question: are your new hires being properly oriented into the company and company culture in their new positions, as well as receiving continued training? Employees should initially be trained through orientation and continued on a regular schedule thereafter. Training gives employees empowerment, competence, and confidence to do their job well resulting in a satisfied customer and employee. Even after you have gone through the previous steps you must still monitor and spot check to insure job duties are being carried out the way you want and expect them to be.

MDS can help you help your employees, customers, and bottom line through providing orientation and training materials, on-site training sessions, over the phone coaching, and group seminars to ensure your team has the tools needed to be successful and provide an excellent customer service experience to current and future clients. MDS also has many years of experience in mystery shopping communities to gather firsthand knowledge of the feel and attitude of a community, as well as monitoring results on an ongoing basis.

I look forward to working with you and your community’s professional team in the very near future. Contact me directly to set up an initial consultation and let’s start the process to an improved customer service experience, higher occupancy rates, and a healthier bottom line.